His land ethic has become a modern classic and may be treated as the standard example, the paradigm case, as it were, ofwhat an environmental ethic iso environmental ethics then can be defined ostensively by using leopolds land ethic as theexemplary type. Baird callicotts acritique ofand an alternative to the wilderness ideais peculiar. The land ethic, moral development, and ecological rationality. Leopold claims the extension of ethics is part ecological evolution a. Earths insights widens the scope of environmental ethics to include the ecological teachings embedded in nonwestern worldviews. Notwithstanding certain superficial similarities, more. He begins by using an analogy from odysseus and his execution of his twelve slavegirls whom he believed misbehaved while. Thought that leo said that the biota is just one individual vs one person individual. Charles starkey 2007 southern journal of philosophy 45 1. Aldo leopold, argues for the land ethic, which attributes intrinsic value more holistically to. The two points of the triangle are leopolds land ethic and benthams humane ethic. Baird callicott is a distinguished research professor at the university of north texas whose work has been at the forefront of the new field of environmental philosophy and ethics. In fact he argues that leopolds land ethic is a modem.
Northern nevada will engage in a number of earth day activities on sunday, including the annual celebration in idlewild park. Baird callicott born 1941 is an american philosopher whose work has been at the forefront of the new field of environmental philosophy and ethics. The above is adapted from an essay by callicott, do deconstructive ecology and sociobiology undermine leopolds land ethic. The central and most recalcitrant problem for environmental ethics is the problem of constructing an adequate theory of intrinsic value for nonhuman natural entities and for nature as a whole. The land ethic is grounded in the general approach to ethics that hume and smith pioneered. Callicott is perhaps best known as the leading contemporary exponent of aldo leopolds land ethic and has more recently explored an aldo leopold earth ethic in response to global climate change. When leopold wrote the land ethic, paradigm in ecology was balance of nature.
This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves. Baird callicott, who is a scholar of aldo leopolds land ethic and uses it in constructing his own environmental ethic. The land ethic, on the other hand, is holistic in the sense that theintegrity, stability, and beauty of the biotic community is its summum bonum. Human nature common point ecological community environmental ethic moral evaluation these keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. Baird callicott the ethical foundations ofthe animal liberation movement are compared with those ofaldo leopolds land ethic, which is taken as the paradigm for environmental ethics in general. I specialized in ancient greek philosophy and still. Pdf aldo leopold, environmental ethics, and the land ethic. Moral pluralism in environmental ethics prabhu venkataraman. On friday, april 29, however, the university of nevada, reno will have the rare opportunity to play host to one of the figures who was there at the beginning of one of the worlds major branches of environmental scholarship. A land ethic of course cannot prevent the alteration, management, and use of these resources, but it does affirm their right to continued existence, and, at least in spots, their continued existence in a natural in short, a land ethic changes the role of homo sapiens from conqueror of the landcommunity to plain member and citizen of it.
An attempt to realize a distinction between anthropogenic changes and natural changes in the environment is a futile effort that introduces far too much philosophy into the debate over environmental conservation. He began as an academic philosopher, but early in his career was motivated by the intellectual challenges posed by the environmental movement. Baird callicott of ethic conservation in the old world seems to have evolved gradually. The introduction presents a straightforward and exciting assessment of the longterm intellectual and cultural significance of the field. A sequel to callicott s pioneering work, in defense of the land ethic, beyond the land ethic engages a wide spectrum of topics central to the field, including the troubled relationship of environmental philosophy to current mainstream academic philosophy. Baird callicott, in defense of the land ethic essays in. Baird callicott the holism of the land ethic and its antecedents. Callicott, father of environmental ethics, to speak on. A sequel to callicotts pioneering work, in defense of the land ethic, beyond the land ethic engages a wide spectrum of topics central to the field, including the troubled relationship of environmental philosophy to current mainstream academic. Baird callicott the darwinian roots of the land ethic or all the environmental ethics so far devised. Contribution to the debate over the value of animals.
For calicott, coming to terms with creating an ethic for the environment is difficult because he feels that at a certain point giving rights to entities such as plants and streams is simply too absurd. A key ingredient in leopolds land ethic was the notion that the community of life itself matters, not just its individual members. Intrinsic value, quantum theory, and environmental ethics j. Essays in environmental philosophy brings into a single volume j. The land ethic individual thinkers since the days of ezekiel. Indigenous worlds and callicotts land ethic request pdf. I specialized in ancient greek philosophy and still am actually. Leopold suggests that there should be a social revolution in that humans, as a whole, should have a more ethical view of land. Baird callicott ranges broadly, exploring the sacred texts of islam, hinduism, jainism, taoism, confucianism, and zen buddhism, as well as the oral traditions of polynesia, north and south america, and australia. The land ethic and the earth ethic, published by oxford university press in 20. It must distinguish itself from both because those are its two main opponents. Environmental virtue, callicott and the land ethic. Choice 1999 outstanding academic book a leading theorist addresses a wide spectrum of topics central to the field of environmental philosophy.
He is a university distinguished research professor and a member of the department of philosophy and religion studies and the institute of applied sciences at the university of north texas. Request pdf indigenous worlds and callicott s land ethic we assess j. Of all the environmental ethics so far devised, the land ethic, first sketched by aldo. Beyond the land ethic will be indispensable to those interested in environmental philosophy. Thinking like a planet the land ethic and the earth ethic j.
A sequel to callicotts pioneering work, in defense of the land ethic, beyond the land ethic engages a wide spectrum of topics central to the field, including the troubled relationship of environmental philosophy to current mainstream academic philosophy. Most people thought of animal liberation had one main opponent, the land ethic. Of all the environmental ethics so far devised, the land ethic, first sketched by aldo leopold, is most popular among professional conservationists and least popular among professional philosophers. Baird callicott is university distinguished research professor at the university of north texas. This seems to be a point of contrast between the land ethic. To preserve the integrity, stability, and beauty of the biotic community. A sequel to callicott s pioneering work, in defense of the land ethic, beyond the land ethic engages a wide spectrum of topics central to the field, including the troubled relationship of environmental philosophy to current mainstream academic. Aldo leopold, the modern father of ethical holism, embraced the moral. In this context tom regan questions the very basis of leopolds land ethic which does not bother about individual species and termed such view as environmental fascism.
The land ethic, callicott argues, is traceable to the moral psychology of david hume and charles darwins classical account of the origin and evolution of humes moral sentiments. Leading scholars critically assess the pioneering environmental philosophy of j. That land is a community is the basic concept of ecology, he writes, but that land is to be loved and respected is an extension of ethics. Callicott held the position of professor of philosophy. However, there is another opponent, ethical humanismhuman moralism. Baird callicotts decadelong effort to articulate, defend, and extend the seminal environmental philosophy of aldo leopold. Darwin argued that all things human including ethics can be understood as having evolved by natural selection from traits possessed by.
Koninklijke brill nv, leiden, 2004 worldviews 8,23 353365. For all his successes, socrates was a selfdescribed poor student when it came to environmental ethics. If we combine two definitions, then ethic is a limitation on. Prospects and problems article pdf available in the journal of value inquiry 432. More essays in environmental philosophy, albany, ny. No doubt, a parallel, but very different, practice and conception of conservation also independently evolved in the new world. Land, value, community provides an indepth critical study of the theories of j. Thus, on callicotts reading, the land ethic would consider it wrong to allow populations of deer for example to increase unchecked and threaten the integrity, stability, and beauty of the biotic community of which they are a part. Callicotts style is vivid, frank, often fun to read, and always clear. Certainly, the leopold land ethic is both holistic and nonanthropocentric.
Baird callicott is professor of philosophy at university of north texas and the author of in defense of the land ethic 1989, and editor of companion to a sand county almanac 1987. Callicott argues from a humean position of human moral sen. Baird callicott, one of the worlds foremost environmental philosophers. Callicott, holistic environmental ethics and the problem of ecofascism photocopied march 1. For instance, baird callicott states that if the land ethic has the. These cardinal values of the leopold land ethic may have to be reviseddynamized, to coin a wordif they are to be ecologically credible. Pdf on jan 1, 2001, michael paul nelson and others published j. Aldo leopolds land ethic challenges the way we look at land and our natural resources. Baird callicott what environmental duties and obligations does human membership in biotic communities generate. See below for a complete listing of the wideranging anthologies and brief texts that focus on a particular theme or topic within one of four areas of applied ethics. Reexamining the darwinian basis for aldo leopolds land ethic. The environmental crisis is global in scope, yet contemporary environmental ethics is centered predominantly in western philosophy and religion.
The land ethic individual thinkers since the days of. With the wholesale devaluation and destruction of american indian cultures that occurred dur. Aldo leopold, environmental ethics, and the land ethic article pdf available in wildlife society bulletin 281. Armstrong, humboldt state university a pleasure to read, this book is significant because it discusses issues that are central to environmental philosophy. Each changing level of society, darwin suggests, saw an.
American indian environmental ethics is part of the basic ethics in action series. Aldo leopold what does leopold mean by biotic right or value. Leopolds famous summary statement of the land ethic is evocative and makes. Need to revise the land ethic in response to this change a. Leopolds land ethic transforms the science of ecology into a worldview, and thus the grounds for a guide to conduct which is to say, an ethic. Baird callicott s attempt in earths insights to reconcile his land ethic with the environmental ethics of indigenous. Baird callicott claims leopolds land ethic the community concept has so far propelled the. Foundationsoflandethic the conceptual foundations of the. Lecture given as part of the philosophical fridays lecture series at the university of southern mississippi.
A leading voice in this new field, callicott sounds the depths of the proverbial iceberg, the tip of which is the land ethic. Callicotts critique of sentientism plants and invertebrates so plants and invertebrate animals, the vast amjority of earths living denizens, remain mere means to e managed for the good of the morally privileged class of sentient or subjectofalife animals. Apr 27, 2011 northern nevada will engage in a number of earth day activities on sunday, including the annual celebration in idlewild park. The land ethic, callicott argues, is traceable to the moral psychology of david hume and charles darwins classical account of the. This book develops an new moral philosophy that is capable of engaging the most urgent and otherwise intractable ethical concern of the first century of the new millennium. Baird callicott ranges broadly, exploring the sacred texts of islam, hinduism, jainism, taoism, confucianism, and zen. He is coeditorinchief of the encyclopedia of environmental ethics and philosophy and author or editor of a score of other books and author of dozens of journal articles, encyclopedia articles, and book chapters in environmental philosophy and ethics. The summary moral maxim, the golden rule, of the land ethic is a thing is right when it tends to preserve the integrity, stability, and beauty of the biotic community. A classical antecedent of some of the formal characteristics of the land ethic is found in platos moral philosophy. Readers will be served well to have callicotts current thinking available to them. In this work, i scrutinize leopolds land ethic and callicotts interpretation of it both from normative and. Aldo leopold, the conservation ethic and the land ethic photocopied.
85 1391 813 1322 582 326 1547 1280 1583 395 837 186 780 232 1566 269 818 772 336 1362 479 766 122 560 116 1160 361 961 11 827 893